Posted Today, 17:17
The opps, if good, will both know we lack the diamond K since we have 13 top tricks if we hold that card. But only the strongest or, ironically most weak, defenders would not give count in their minor holdings when discarding. So I echo David’s request that you tell us precisely which cards were played to every trick after the first two.
Why you don’t provide that is a mystery. You present a play problem where, in real life, we may very well glean useful inferences from the carding yet you don’t tell us who played what card in what order. Yes, WC opps, playing well, won’t tell us what’s going on, but I’m willing to bet this hand wasn’t played against WC defenders. Weak defenders may not know how to give count when discarding but they make up for it by often evincing pressure as we run our hearts because they don’t plan ahead.
Since I’d not be making a blind guess in real life, I refuse to make one here.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari